JACC Adv
Why cutting saturated fat helps some patients more than others

Clinical takeaway: When counseling patients with elevated LDL cholesterol, emphasize that dietary saturated fat reduction may have a particularly large impact in some individuals. Patients who appear especially sensitive to dietary changes may warrant renewed attention to nutrition as part of LDL-lowering management.
Clinicians have long observed that some patients see meaningful cholesterol reductions after changing their diets, while others do not. This study suggests that genetic differences may account for some of that variability, potentially helping explain ongoing debates over how strongly saturated fat influences cardiovascular risk at the individual level.
Researchers analyzed data from 20,940 postmenopausal women and confirmed the established association between higher saturated fat intake and higher LDL cholesterol. However, that relationship varied substantially across the genetic spectrum. A 5% increase in calories from saturated fat (replacing carbohydrates) was associated with an approximately 2 mg/dL increase in LDL cholesterol overall, with much larger effects observed among participants with the highest genetic predisposition to elevated LDL levels.
Among 16,835 participants without preexisting ASCVD, 1,582 cardiovascular events occurred over a median follow-up of 10 years. Higher saturated fat intake was associated with increased ASCVD risk primarily among the top 25% of participants by genetic risk score, while little association was seen in the remaining 75%.
Participants with both high genetic risk and high saturated fat intake had a 10-year ASCVD incidence of 14.3%, compared with 9.5% among those with lower genetic risk and lower saturated fat intake. Those with both high genetic risk and high saturated fat intake also had a roughly 45% higher risk of ASCVD during follow-up.
Investigators used dietary questionnaires, lipid measurements, and genetic data from the Women’s Health Initiative to assess whether a polygenic risk score for LDL cholesterol modified the association between saturated fat intake and LDL levels. The primary outcome was LDL cholesterol; incident ASCVD served as a secondary outcome.
The findings support a future "precision prevention" approach, but the authors caution that evidence is not yet sufficient to use polygenic risk scores to guide dietary recommendations. They call for randomized dietary intervention trials to determine whether genetics should inform individualized nutrition counseling.
“We don’t yet have evidence that polygenic risk scores should be used to guide diet recommendations. But that certainly is a future area of study, and from what our results in this new study suggest, could indeed be a fruitful one,” said Shoa Clarke, MD, PhD, senior author.
Source: Barad A, et al. (2026 Nov 18) JACC Adv. Association Between Saturated Fat Intake and Low-Density Lipoprotein Cholesterol Across the Genetic Spectrum